Movie Review: Mr. Monk’s Last Case

Just to start off: I am a major Monk-aholic. I’ve seen every episode at least twice, plus read most of the excellent tie-in novels by Lee Goldberg. So naturally, I was thrilled to see an advertisement on Peacock for a brand new Monk movie. I watched Mr. Monk’s Last Case on the day it released – December 8th – and I’ve been wanting, maybe needing, to talk about it ever since.

The first thing fans need to know is that this movie has an underlying tone of despair which was not typical of the original series. I noticed by chance in the upper corner of the screen that one of the warnings on the film was for suicide. I frowned, thinking this might be an unintentional spoiler for the case Monk would be investigating. Not so.

The reason for the warning quickly becomes clear in the movie’s early scenes. Mr. Monk is not doing well at all. In fact, he is deeply depressed and planning to end his own life.

When last we saw Adrian, he was euphoric from finally solving his wife’s murder, and happily building a relationship with his newly-discovered step-daughter, Molly. But more than a decade has passed between then and now, and times have definitely changed. Over the course of the movie, we learn it’s not one big thing causing Monk’s depression, but rather a series of events and feelings that have all chipped at him over time.

Most of his loved ones have scattered and moved away, including Natalie. Monk is no longer working as a police consultant, and the only people he regularly interacts with are Molly, Dr. Bell, and Trudy (in the form of ghostly visions). Monk’s social isolation is sharp and palpable.

The pandemic dealt his mental health another crippling blow, causing a resurgence of his agoraphobia as well as cranking up his OCD to unbearable levels. Although Monk lived to see the other side, he never truly recovered from the trauma of being that afraid for so long.

There’s been much talk about how we all came out of the pandemic psychologically worse for wear. Whether or not you got the virus, whether or not you personally knew someone who passed away, we all have scars. No one came out of those years unscathed.

But there hasn’t been as much discussion about how it affected the people who were already struggling with demons like depression, germaphobia, isolation, etc. before Covid, how much worse it was for them. By now, most of the world has moved on, but there is this forgotten group of people who physically survived, but never fully came back. In some ways, I am one of them.

I appreciated that the movie talked about this, and using Mr. Monk as an example was the perfect way to explore the issue – a beloved character who is already well-known for his mental health battles, so we’d easily be able to understand just how hard everything hit him.

Monk’s suicidal intent is the dark current running beneath the rest of the plot, which features many of the character returns and emotional moments fans will be expecting.

The regular gang reunites for this adventure, including Stottlemeyer, Natalie, Randy, and Dr. Bell, all portrayed by their original actors. Trudy’s spirit plays an important role here, just as she did in the series, and Sharona appears in a flashback, so she is included as well.

The only recast is Molly, originally played by Alona Tal (aka Jo on Supernatural). Not sure why they cast a different actress for the film – possibly they wanted someone with a more easy, free-spirited vibe? – but it shouldn’t bother people too much as Molly’s only appearance on the original series was for probably about 60 seconds in the last episode, and the new actress, Caitlin McGee, does a great job.

The movie hits all the right beats for a typical Monk story:

  • Randy presents an outlandish “theory” about the case, complete with an equally ridiculous visual aid.
  • The Randy Disher Project gets a hilarious shout-out.
  • Adrian plays his clarinet (incorrectly identified in the closed captioning as an oboe).
  • Stottlemeyer grumpily disagrees with Monk about the prime suspect.
  • Monk gets to say his classic, “He’s the guy.”
  • Natalie and Monk team up to investigate, resulting in numerous car crashes and lots of hysterical screaming (Monk being the screamer, of course).
  • The bad guy looks like he’s going to get away with it.
  • Monk gets that smile on his face when he finally solves the case, closely followed by, “Here’s what happened…”

Another highlight was the introduction of the new, cooler-than-cool police captain, Lisa Rudner, who obviously knows a valuable asset when she sees one. She makes it very clear she wants Monk to return as a consultant. Although Rudner isn’t in this first movie that much (yes, despite the movie’s “last case” title, I would be surprised if they didn’t make another one), her brief scenes show that she cares more about getting justice for victims than about politics or appearances – a sharp contrast to Captain Stottlemeyer in his early days, when he hated having Monk called in on a case because it might make the captain and his officers look incompetent.

Overall, the mystery is not the most complex or well-written one in the history of the series, and there are a few plot holes I won’t get into here to avoid being spoilery, but emotion is the true engine of this story, and the movie has that in spades. From the devastatingly personal nature of the case to Monk’s private battle with depression, there is more than enough substance here to elevate the storyline to the status of a movie as opposed to just a super-sized episode.

Despite the many wonderful comedic moments, the sadness is what stayed with me most, so much so that when I walked in on my mom watching an old Monk episode the other day, my heart twisted at the knowledge of what is to come for this character, what he will have to endure before finally coming back into the light again.

And, yes, Mr. Monk does survive the movie. But not because one of his friends runs up at the last moment to knock the pills out of his hand. Despite Monk’s cryptic comments throughout the movie, and the concerned looks he gets from Natalie, Molly, and even Stottlemeyer, no one seems to know exactly how close he is to ending it all, and that’s scary.

Monk’s psychiatrist has a better idea of what’s going on than anyone else, and there’s an extremely touching scene that brings them both to tears (me too). But no matter how many people tell Monk he is loved and needed, it just doesn’t seem to sink in.

And as desperately as I wanted someone to get through to him, to shake him and yell at him and tie him down until he finally listened, in the end the decision to live comes from within Monk himself. I think it has to. The way it happens is sweet and special and I won’t spoil it, but it is worth seeing – just like the movie itself.

Honestly, I don’t know if it will hit most people as hard as it did me. It’s all about what you’ve been through, and what you’re going through right now. I’ve known three people who’ve taken their own lives, so this movie dredged up a lot of that old pain. For viewers without that personal history, it might just be like a regular Monk episode. For others, it might be too hard to even watch. Graphic images of Monk hoarding and counting out prescription sleeping pills, opening a high-rise window as if to jump out, writing goodbye letters to all of his loved ones – these could be triggers for people who are already on the brink.

In the end, I think it was an important movie exploring the after-effects of the pandemic on those who were already in crisis. It made me want to listen to “Hate Me” by Blue October. It made me want to check up on the people in my life. It made me want to check up on myself.

If you’re reading this, and you’re feeling some dark thoughts, I hope this movie inspires you to reach out for help. Or reach inward, as Monk does, and see the value you bring to this big, scary, wonderful world and the people in it. A value only you can bring.

We’re never as alone as we think we are, and neither is Mr. Monk. (Keep watching past the credits, and you’ll see what I mean.)

Stay safe, take care of each other, and have a Happy New Year.

~G

Carrying On

 

I wish I could say that I’ve been one of those people who used the downtime of quarantine to become massively productive. I wish I could say I holed up and penned five epic novels, got completely ripped, and launched a successful business or two. I tip my imaginary hat to the people who can say that – you have my respect, my awe, and my envy.

I could give a list of excuses for why I’m not a pandemic wunderkind. I have many legitimate ones. Like the fourteen cats and kittens someone dumped on our property back in April, when all the vets and shelters were closed. (You can read all about this crazy event here.) I could point out that I have extra responsibilities helping to care for a family member suffering from a debilitating illness. I could complain about how draining and complicated a simple trip to the grocery store has become.

Like I said, I have many valid excuses. But the truth is, I have struggled just to get normal daily tasks done. Tasks that were hardly a burden before this all happened suddenly seem exhausting after so many grueling months of fear and uncertainty. I turned forty last month. I felt sixty-five. This situation has aged all of us, I think. When I wake up each day, I try very hard to be happy. Once in a while, it dawns on me that I didn’t used to have to try.

I’ve had a few pandemic-induced nightmares, all of them variations on same theme: I’m out in public, walking around shopping or whatever, and suddenly I realize I’m not wearing my mask. It’s horrifying. I quickly grab the collar of my shirt or coat and try vainly to cover up my nose and mouth but it’s never enough. Everyone around me is wearing their masks like good citizens, and here I am, completely naked – and not in a fun, nude beach kind of way. Oddly, no one appears to be judging me. But I am judging myself. I am judging myself so hard. I wake up feeling relieved the event never actually occurred, and grateful, because to date I haven’t lost anyone to COVID. The shadow creeps ever closer as more of my community members begin to fall victim, but for the moment I am lucky. The people who’ve watched their loved ones die via iPad screens, those are the folks who have real nightmares.

As this pandemic has dragged on, many things have slipped through the cracks in my life. This blog is one. Writing is another. Exercise would also have to be included on that list. I tried to put on my aerobics DVD one time during the lockdown, only to discover the disc was broken and wouldn’t play. Months of sloth-like inactivity later, I mustered the energy to hunt down a thirty-minute workout on YouTube. I barely survived the ordeal and for days afterward hobbled around with every muscle screaming like I’d been in a serious car accident.

I miss blogging. I miss connecting with other writers and fans. I miss being in some form of decent physical shape. I really, really miss writing on a regular basis.

It is time, slowly and with many faltering steps, to rectify all of these things. There is reason to hope, even under this oppressive cloud of darkness. The scent of spring is in the air, faint but undeniable: promising new vaccines, a new American President, more people doing the right thing and wearing their masks. The end is still a long way off, no question, but it is in sight. And in the meantime, like Luna Lovegood says in the final Harry Potter book, “We’re still here. We’re still fighting.”

So, my friends, let’s carry on.

Courage, Loss, and Love on the Back Porch

It happens around the same time every spring – a pair of purple finches, darting around the pillars of our wraparound porch, tufts of dried grass clutched in their little wedge-shaped beaks. They usually build their nest in the northwest corner, and we get to watch in delight as their fledglings transform from helpless, naked little T-Rexes into graceful ballerinas of the sky.

One year the birds were so successful they immediately reused the same nest to raise a second brood. Another year the nest blew down before they’d even laid their eggs. That time, the finches rebuilt elsewhere, seeming to have lost faith in their most trusted nesting spot. The following year they were back again, as if nothing bad had ever happened.

Which brings us to this year. 2020. This crazy, scary, nothing-will-ever-be-the-same-again year. The purple finches came right on schedule, just like always. Their presence was an achingly welcome sight. Here we were in the midst of a lockdown, a pandemic, facing uncertainty in almost every aspect of our human lives. And yet, for these birds, it was business as usual. For some reason, they built their nest in the northeast corner this time. For obvious reasons, we watched them more avidly than ever before.

The new nesting location quickly became a concern. There was an enormous pine tree right beside that corner of the porch that was literally tearing our house apart. It had to come down before any more damage was done, and the operation was going to be long and loud. We knew the finches already had eggs in the nest, and quite possibly newborn chicks. We dreaded what would happen on tree removal day. If the mother bird had to stay off the nest for too long, the brood would surely perish.

On the morning the pine was scheduled to come down, I woke up early, my stomach twisting like an anxious boa constrictor. All day long, I winced and cringed at every scream of the chainsaw, every testosterone-fueled bellow from the cutting crew, every ground-shaking thump as another section of the tree struck the earth. I kept looking at my phone, calculating how many hours they’d been at it – one, two, three, four. Every time I checked, my heart dipped a little more, as the chicks’ survival chances went down, down, down.

In the midst of the chaos, I peeked at the nest a few times, only to find it empty, of course. When the job was finally done, the crew left, their truck’s massive tires cracking over plywood placed on the lawn in the vain hope of protecting our grass. I held my breath, waiting for the mother bird to return. I let out a huge sigh when she landed back on the nest about fifteen minutes after their departure.

I immediately went inside to assure my mom, who’d been fretting over the nest just as much as I, that the bird had returned. Despite the good news, I also shared my fear that four-plus hours was simply too long for the female finch to have been off the nest.

“She wasn’t,” my mom said.

“What?” I asked.

“She wasn’t off the nest for that many hours. She came back in the middle and sat on those eggs. In the midst of all that sawing and yelling, that brave little bird came back.”

A huge grin broke across my face. I rose up on my toes and peered out over our lacy curtains at the tiny gray-brown bird dutifully seated on her nest. The commotion of the tree coming down had made me nervous, and I understood what was going on. I couldn’t imagine the courage it took for the mother finch to fly right into the epicenter of all that chaos and sit on her clutch when every instinct must’ve been screaming at her to flee. She might’ve been a dainty, delicate little lady, but she had the heart of a lion, for sure.

A bewildered squirrel investigates the stump of the fallen pine. Luckily we found no evidence of a nest in the branches.

With the tree crisis in our rear-view mirror, our family went back to enjoying the peace and quiet as we watched the nest for signs of new life. A few days later, there was a dramatic uptick in activity, with the mother bird frequently flying off for brief periods. Whenever she was sitting on the nest, she constantly leaned down to tenderly nuzzle something underneath her. Though it would still be several days before those ugly, reptilian heads popped up, we knew our little avian friends had made their debut.

Momma Finch was a quick hunter-gatherer. She’d light off for a short bit, then return just as fast with a regurgitated snack for the brood. I loved watching her groom the chicks and nudge them gently with her beak before flying away once more. As the babies grew, so did her job – feeding them, keeping them warm, cleaning up after them.

“Does the father finch help her at all?” my dad asked one evening as we watched the mother deliver her last feeding of the night.

“Not really,” I replied. “He hardly ever shows up.”

My dad laughed and rolled his eyes. “That son of a gun!”

“He helps a little,” I amended, feeling the need to defend the guy.

In truth, I rarely saw the father bird, but the few times I did he was a sight to behold. Vivid red feathers splashed his head and chest, making his mate plain and dull by comparison. I have no idea how he spent most of the day, but the rare times he did arrive at the nest, it was quite the spectacle: excited screeching, frantic flapping. The chicks were obviously beside themselves, but it was their mom whose brown wings were beating so hard they blurred. It was she who screeched the loudest, turning into a chick herself as he fed her a little bit of regurgitated seeds or fruit.

Ah, I get it, I thought. She takes care of the chicks, he takes care of her.

Of course, she was fully capable of feeding herself, but what new mom doesn’t need a bit of pampering, a little “me time,” a small reminder that someone appreciates all of her sacrifices?

He did that for her, and she loved him to pieces for it.

A male Baltimore Oriole snacks on an orange.

As the baby birds began to fledge, we looked forward to their first flight, and fretted over whether they might fall out of the next too soon…and land right in the waiting jaws of our porch cat, Joey, who’d taken to sleeping right under the nest.

As it turned out, though, the cat wasn’t what we needed to worry about.

I came in from my chores late one afternoon to find my mom standing anxiously at the window.

“What’s wrong?” I asked.

“Have you seen the mother bird lately?”

I frowned. “I saw her feeding them at around 11, but not since then. Why?”

“She’s been gone all afternoon,” Mom told me. “It’s not like her to leave them for so long.”

We spent the next few hours peering out the window, our anxiety spiking each time we saw a hungry little head waving above the nest and no mother bird there to feed it. My mom started voicing her fears that something bad had happened to the female, that she was injured, or possibly worse.

I didn’t want to believe it, and kept looking outside even as dusk fell, still hoping for the mother bird’s triumphant return. One time as I stood on my toes, scanning for any sign of her, I noticed a small, motionless shape lying out on the highway. A bubble of dread blossomed in my heart as I slipped on my sandals to go investigate. The bubble grew as I approached the flattened form of what was obviously a bird that had been struck by a car. It was nearly dark then, and I had to get very close before I was sure.

It was the mother finch. She was dead.

I walked slowly back to the house and delivered the news.

“The fledglings will die,” my dad said sadly, gazing out at the nest.

“Can you take care of them?” my mom asked me desperately, knowing I’d raised baby birds in the past with some success.

I bit my lip. “I can try if I have to, but first let’s see if the father bird starts feeding them. They’ll be better off with him than me.”

As darkness continued to fall, I was practically glued to the window. Come on, Poppa Finch, I silently begged. They need you, now. They’re your babies too.

Just as I was about to turn away in defeat, a flash of vivid scarlet caught my eye. My heart skipped and I pressed my nose to the glass, not caring that I was making a greasy smudge. It was him. He had finally come.

I imagine he was quite shocked when he arrived at the nest that first night. Here he was, expecting to find an ecstatic wife flapping happily for her treat and instead he got a nest full of loud, hungry chicks with no momma bird in sight. Whatever was going through his head, instinct kicked in and he immediately began to feed the chicks.

“He’s here!” I exclaimed to my parents. “He’s feeding them!”

The relief in our house that night was sweeter than music. Of course, we all knew one feeding wasn’t going to cut it. This male finch was going to have to recognize that his mate was never coming back. He was going to have to step up in a way he never had before and take care of these chicks full time – feeding them all day, every day, and cleaning the nest, too.

The next week was an anxious one as we catalogued the male finch’s activities. He didn’t feed the chicks as often as his wife had, but he seemed to give them more food when he did come. Possibly he had a larger crop than she did. He was definitely more efficient, depositing regurgitated fruit and seeds in each wide screaming mouth with almost robotic precision. He made sure everyone got something, every time. No small feat, especially considering that the brood was an extra-large one. Normally, the finches had three or four chicks per clutch. This year, they’d had a whopping five.

Poppa Finch takes care of the brood.

The father finch didn’t sit on the chicks, or spend nearly as much time nuzzling them as his mate had, but that was okay. He gave them what they needed. He gave them life. And when the time came, he took them safely out into the world. They didn’t leave the nest all at once, as they had in previous years. It was staggered–first two, then another two, then finally the last little straggler. Maybe he had to split them up because he was a single parent, and flight training five birds at once was just too daunting. He did a good job, though. Much to our relief (and Joey’s disappointment) not a single one of them fell into feline clutches.

Now, they’re all out in the great big wild somewhere, maybe still with their father, or maybe already starting to form families of their own. Maybe one of them will be back next year with a mate, ready to start the cycle anew.

Already, their mother must have faded into the backs of their minds. They’ve probably forgotten what she looked like. They were so young when she died, it’ll be a miracle if they have any memory of her at all.

I hope they do, though. Probably not anything concrete, or solid, or tangible, but maybe just a feeling they get when they’re perched on a branch with summer breeze rustling through their feathers, and their eyes are just starting to close. A sensation of warm feathers blanketing them in protection, or the gentle phantom touch of a beak nuzzling them. Or maybe they’ll hear a call in the distance, and for one second it’ll take them back to that nest where everything started. Back to her.

However it happens I hope for just a moment before they fall asleep each night, some deep-down part of them remembers a love that braved chainsaws and falling logs and yelling men to keep her babies safe. A love that was greater than fear, stronger than instinct.

A mother’s love.